Andy on Twitter

  • Very clever... A Microsoft Excel Artist ,
  • While the problem underlying M&A integration is big, Material Information Platforms implemented pre-transaction wil… ,
  • Wow... t/sheets acquired by Intuit ,
  • Way to start the morning. Beautiful Balmoral.. Balmoral Sailing Club ,
  • Bank inquiry puts global investment at risk: Westpac's David Lindberg.. spot on ,
  • Why are taxi apps so appalling. Slow, lousy interface, freeze... hopeless attempt to satisfy customers and so easily fixed,
  • should give us the option of only accepting drivers who aren’t on a job. Stop “forcing” drivers to take a job while on a job. ,
  • National looks more desperate every day. NZ is lucky to have a leader with this much experience. ,
  • Dennis clearly doesn’t understand that a BYO challenge for the last AC was well past 200m. Unless you sailed Oracle… ,
  • And that’s the point - Amazon is a boost to SMBs and entrepreneurs locked out by big retail. And so much for big br… ,
  • Little evidence in here of impact in meetings but suspect the same applies. Laptops Are Great. But Not During a Lec… ,
  • To Grow Talent, Don’t Move Fast and Break Things — Move Slow and Build Them .. so right ,
  • Who cares if it is. NZs PM is doing the right thing. ,
  • Great win for and cool work by ,
  • The pressure to use all those extra characters is too much...,
  • Connect

Ah, The Peace & Tranquility Of The Blogosphere…

One of the things I enjoy most about Nicholas Carr’s blog is his honesty. No punches pulled there.

And this morning he slammed a post by Edleman blogger, Steve Rubell on comments by Yahoo bloggers on stuff that buggs them about their products… Steve says:

I like companies and products that have the guts to say “we suck” or something close to it. It’s very un PR. It says to me, “hey, we want a best of breed product and we’re going to work our butts off to give it to you.”

Nick says:

Do companies actually pay for this kind of knuckleheaded advice? The last we thing we need is companies getting in touch publicly with their inner suckiness. Just give me something I want to buy and shut the hell up. I have enough friends.

Frankly, I don’t have the time to hang about reading companies navel gazing on their own products. As Steve says at the end of his post, actions speak louder than words. And, as a Yahoo shareholder I’d rather see focus on execution than dissent. Just cause Microsoft is doing it doesn’t mean it is right for others.

The problem with this kind of internal activism is it mostly points to problems and not solutions. In fact, they probably can’t even speak to the solutions. All this has done is encouraged me to stick with iLife for all my personal stuff and not continue to play with Yahoo 360. Is that what Yahoo wanted – Less participants?

At the end of the say I’m OK with a company talking about its shortcomings so long as it is talking about what it is doing about them and not whineing. Make your ‘bitch lists’ action lists and we would all be thrilled. The tone and nature of this kind of dialogue is rich and important to internal teams – IMHO, it adds little externally.

I’m glad Steve feels better for it. I feel worse, worse for Yahoo – a company with products I really like.

One Response

  1. By Ed O’Meara on May 26th, 2006 at 12:16 pm

    Andy,

    I think Rubel and friends are rationalizing all their web-based clients that feel no pressure to leave Beta stage… and have you noticed that we no longer even hear “wait until version 3” when talking about Microsoft. Sucky companies have made “shipping” irrelevant and “code complete” a relic of the past.

    All the more reason I agree that Apple has a brighter future.

Speak Up — Add Your Thoughts

Connections

  • Connect
How did you connect?   [?]
Indulgences-Coffee